
How to have hard conversations in healthcare
In this video, leadership expert Dennis McIntee shares 3 questions to ask yourself before stepping into hard conversations. These questions help you get centered and clear about the goal, so you can navigate the situation with clarity and care.
As a physician, learning how to have hard conversations in healthcare is essential, as you will inevitably face situations that require difficult discussions with colleagues, staff and patients.
It could be with a colleague who isn’t pulling their weight or someone on your staff whose propensity for gossip is polluting the team culture.
Or maybe you have to give difficult feedback, address a conflict, or talk with someone who struggles to take responsibility.
Before looking up tips on how to have hard conversations, you first need to examine yourself.
The only person you can control during a hard conversation is you. So when you step in with a clear understanding of the issue and your ideal outcome, you can lead the conversation more effectively.
Because the reality is that you’ll never change what you’re unwilling to confront. And you’ll never confront what you’re afraid of.
The three questions we encourage all leaders to ask before hard conversations help you get to the root of your fears.
Once you’ve confronted your own fears, frustrations, or insecurities, you can show up as a calm, centered leader who can navigate hard conversations well.
Start With Yourself
Confrontation doesn’t come naturally to everyone. And hard conversations tend to bring up a lot of emotion for everyone involved.
For that reason, many physicians would prefer to ignore the issues altogether. But dismissing recurring issues, team conflict, or unacceptable behaviors rarely ends with resolution.
Instead, it causes deeper issues to develop over time that can risk retention of high performers, the reputation of your practice, and overall results.
Fears and insecurities may be driving your avoidance. That’s why the first step in any hard conversation is to ask yourself what you hope to accomplish.
3 Questions to Ask Before Hard Conversations
Our research shows that asking the following three questions helps you prepare yourself for navigating a healthy, hard conversation:
- What do I want for myself?
- What do I want for the other person?
- What do I want for the working relationship?
Start with yourself. What do you personally hope to achieve with the conversation?
As a physician, you spend a lot of time focused on the well-being of others, so it may feel surprisingly difficult to answer this question for yourself.
Maybe you want:
- To feel respected
- To establish a clear expectation
- To address an ongoing issue
- To protect your team’s culture
- To clarify your role and responsibilities
When you know your personal desire for the conversation, you can minimize your own defensiveness as you work toward a solution.
Next, ask what you want for the other person.
This question helps keep you focused on specific behaviors rather than the whole person with whom you are having the hard conversation.
You may want the other person to:
- Enjoy coming to work
- Take accountability for their actions
- Feel supported as they grow
You can’t control how the person responds during or after the conversation, but having their best interests in mind can help you maintain a calm demeanor and caring tone throughout the interaction.
After all, your body language and tone communicates far more to the other person than your words do. Start there and you’ll have a greater chance of success.
Finally, ask what you want for the working relationship.
Here’s where you can bring it all together.
Maybe you want:
- To work together in harmony
- To be honest with each other
- To rebuild trust
Plenty of physicians approach hard conversations without considering how they want the working relationship to feel afterward. As a result, they might unintentionally create rifts in the relationship that require even more hard conversations to repair.
So start by understanding what you want the relationship to feel like following the conversation, and consider sharing this with the other person during your conversation.
Clarifying that you have hopes for an ongoing, healthy working relationship with the other person can lower their defenses and help them see that you have a desire to work through the issue rather than pointing fingers or cutting ties.
Preparing for Hard Conversations: Practical Examples
Imagine you have someone on your team who is complaining with others about issues on the team without addressing it directly with you.
Here’s how this process might look before you have a hard conversation:
What do I want…
- For me: I want to feel like I know what’s going on within my team and have the opportunity to address any issues or conflicts
- For the other person: I want them to know they can come to me with complaints instead of spreading discord among others
- For the relationship: I want us to be able to communicate openly and work in harmony
Notice that none of these answers are about controlling the other person. You only have control over yourself. But answering these three questions before confronting anyone helps ensure you create an atmosphere where they are more likely to be receptive to your feedback and your ideas for moving forward.
Or perhaps you have someone on your staff who has become increasingly short with patients and coworkers.
You might initially feel frustrated or angry with the staff member. (And imagine how a conversation fueled by those emotions would go… probably not very well!)
Instead of immediately stepping into a conversation with those emotions, see what happens when you ask these three questions:
- What do I want for me? I want a respectful work environment.
- What do I want for the other person? I want them to understand how their behavior is affecting others and have the opportunity to make a change.
- What do I want for the relationship? I want us to have enough trust that we can talk honestly when something isn’t working.
Now, the conversation is an opportunity to provide clear, specific, honest feedback about someone’s behavior rather than just venting your own frustration.
Get Centered for Hard Conversations
It’s not easy to have hard conversations. But asking these three questions before getting started helps you step in with the right mindset and attitude.
These questions prompt you to:
- Confront your own fears, frustrations, and insecurities
- Get clear on what you want for yourself, the other person, and the working relationship
- Center yourself before you say a single word
Hard conversations are rarely about the words. Start by looking at yourself, clarifying your goals for the conversation, and getting centered as a calm leader who is in control of themself.
You can do it!
Want weekly wellness and leadership insights like this sent straight to your inbox? Click here to sign up for free.
About the Author
Dennis McIntee, a business consultant, gifted keynote speaker, executive coach and author, travels across the world speaking at leadership summits, management training events and health care conferences, to name a few. His three-decade career included stints in Africa, Poland, Germany, and throughout greater Europe where he coached and consulted with growing leaders. Through his experience, Dennis developed a systematic approach to helping his clients reach their goals through coaching, speaking, courses, and teaching techniques that enact transformational change.
Ultimately, Dennis is passionate about helping leaders create high-trust, high-performance cultures while becoming the best version of themselves they can be.
Dennis is also the author of The 8 Qualities of Drama Free Teams, The Power of Pursuit, and Drama Free Teams in Health Care. He has been married to his wife, Lisa, for over 30 years and together they have four children. Dennis is an avid runner and enjoys training for races.

